Plot

The lives of a realtor, a plumber and a former tennis star unexpectedly collide, exposing America’s obsession with true crime, murder and the slow-close toilet seat.
Streaming data by JustWatch via TMDB. Catalogs change, so check the service before you subscribe.

The lives of a realtor, a plumber and a former tennis star unexpectedly collide, exposing America’s obsession with true crime, murder and the slow-close toilet seat.
Official Trailer · Watch on YouTube
In airing order. Open a season to see every episode.

A realtor and a former tennis star struggle to stay afloat as a serial killer puts LA on alert.

Ava and Nathan try to maintain appearances; detectives question Nathan at work; Matt asks to meet.

Ava and Nathan spar with Matt for creative control; Nathan struggles to keep his story straight.

Ava, Nathan and Matt attend a true crime convention; a surprise panelist threatens the podcast.

After a shocking incident at CrimeCon, Ava and Nathan probe Matt for the truth.

Ava and Nathan attend a charity auction at Ruby's mansion, where new and old wounds are laid bare.

Nathan reckons with a devastating failure; Ava confronts her buyer; Matt takes a new approach.

With the cards finally on the table, Ava and Nathan race against time to prevent a tragedy.
Season two finds new parents Ava and Nathan Bartlett three months into parenthood. Focused on taking care of her family, Ava is determined to resist her true crime obsession and return to work as a real estate agent while Nathan trains private tennis clients. But a series of new murders pulls her back in - is Matt behind the slayings? Is Tory, now entangled in a relationship with Matt, in danger?

Ava and Nathan struggle with parenthood and try to convince Matt to return home.

Ava tries to make new friends but gets interrogated; Matt helps Nathan stand up for himself.

Ava investigates a crime scene and runs into an old friend; Nathan takes a risk seeking redemption.

Ava and Nathan go to a sex party to rekindle their spark; Matt is confronted by a fellow addict.

Nathan plays a redemption match; Ava and Matt decode a cipher from the new killer haunting LA.

Ava and Nathan look for Drew; Matt and Tory plan their wedding, but he gives into his dark desires.

Matt's past comes back to haunt Ava and Nathan; Ava realizes her obsession has become an addiction.

Ava and Nathan are on a game show with deadly stakes; Tory and Matt are on the run from the police.
Created by: Craig Rosenberg · Directed by: Alexander Buono, Anu Valia, Jennifer Arnold, Jenée LaMarque · Written by: Craig Rosenberg, Jaclyn Moore, Sono Patel, Max Searle
Kaley CuocoAva Bartlett
Chris MessinaNathan Bartlett
Tom BatemanMatt Pierce
Liana LiberatoTory Thompson
Priscilla QuintanaRuby Gale
June Diane RaphaelRomy Lipinski
Jessica St. ClairRochelle Lipinski
Annabelle Dexter-JonesSerena
Melissa FumeroDrew
Li Jun LiMichelle
Aisha Alfa5 episodes
Sebastian Quinn5 episodes
Alex Alomar Akpobome4 episodes
Brandon Keener4 episodes
Miles Mussenden4 episodes
Aaron Staton4 episodes
Sara Paxton4 episodes
Belmont Cameli3 episodes
Timm Sharp3 episodes
Matthew Law3 episodes
Natalia Dyer2 episodes
Britney Ortiz2 episodes
Pierson Fodé2 episodes
Yvonne Senat Jones2 episodes
Kingston Rumi Southwick2 episodes
Stephanie Allynne2 episodes
Rory Scovel2 episodes
Briana Cuoco2 episodes
Devin Way2 episodes
Brenda Koo2 episodes
Elisa Bocanegra2 episodes
Joe Williamson2 episodes
April Wilkner1 episodes
Jill Lover1 episodes15 stills (6 in 4K) and 12 posters. Tap to enlarge; stills can be downloaded in full size.
Peacock with a subscription; rent or buy on Amazon, Apple TV and more.
Canada: Club Illico, StackTV and fuboTV with a subscription; free on Global TV; rent or buy on Apple TV and Amazon; UK: Disney+ and Sky Go with a subscription; rent or buy on Apple TV, Amazon and more; Singapore: HBO Max with a subscription; Malaysia: HBO Max with a subscription.
2 seasons and 16 episodes so far (as of Nov 16, 2026).
No. TMDB lists the show as canceled after 2 seasons.
Why Women Kill2019
Claws2017
Divorce2016
Santa Clarita Diet2017
No Good Deed2024
You're the Worst2014
56 Days2026
BEEF2023
And Just Like That…2021
Flaked2016
Kevin Can F**K Himself2021
Love2016